IUP Publications Online
Home About IUP Magazines Journals Books Archives
     
A Guided Tour | Recommend | Links | Subscriber Services | Feedback | Subscribe Online
 
The IUP Journal of English Studies :
“Not So Comical”: Tintin, Popular Culture, and the Othering of Spaces
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

The Tintin comic series by Hergé is probably one of the most famous comic series globally. Tintin’s detective sagas are as much a narrative of a sleuth in pursuit of criminals as they are a gaze into the cultural spaces of the countries that Tintin visits. And therein lies the scope for the readers to engage in a critical relationship with the author’s depiction of those spaces. Hergé’s delineation of Asia (Tibet), America (especially the Red Indians), or even South America is replete with cultural and sociological biases with racial overtones. Tintin as a ‘subject’ works by imbibing the colonial/White energy, journeying from the center (Europe) to the margins (non-European places). Behind the visual scope of engaging the children with ‘fantasy’ within a mode of popular culture is Hergé’s political standpoint of seeing the Other from a colonial standpoint, which can be critiqued, problematized, and interrogated through a postcolonial debate. This paper engages in such a debate as to how Hergé stereotypes the Other using colonial energy even when he writes within a popular cultural mode, with Capitalist interventionist strategy, to make his comics appeal to an audience who will consume the Other on the basis of “fantasy” and “unknowability,” thereby thriving on biased representation of non-colonial marginalized spaces.

 
 
 

In 1929, the first book in the Tintin series, Tintin in the Land of the Soviets, was published in Le Petit Vingtième, and it was a time when arts and literature were at a crossroads in Europe. The High Modernism of the Eliots, Joyces, and Baudelaires was about to give way to a more postmodern representation of art and literature, and an animation series definitely fitted more into a postmodern pastiche than a modernist representation of “high art”.

Hergé’s Tintin series, one of the most popular in the history of global animation series, is constructed primarily to feed the cult of the masses that seeks to construct identity in terms of consumerist capitalism. It must be pointed out that “mass culture” and “popular culture” have often been used interchangeably, but the finer nuances show that the two terms cannot be unproblematically used for each other. “Mass culture” relates to the kind of culture that begins to get produced in the postindustrial Europe when the traditional centers of power like family, feudalism, and aristocracy begin to break down, with human capital as its biggest investment. “Popular culture,” however, is more directed towards the process of mass consumption and hence is produced within the matrix of capitalist interventionist politics. If we put animation in general and Tintin in particular within the folds of “popular culture,” then we will see that the approach is to use entertainment as a saleable quality in order to create a “market” for the text.

 
 
 

English Studies Journal, “Not So Comical”, Asia (Tibet), Tintin series, tribal America, Red Indians, “East”, Tintin, Popular Culture, Othering of Spaces.